“How one leads or shephe…

“How one leads or shepherds one’s flock is every bit as important as what one accomplishes.”

Bishop Richard G. Lennon recently acknowledged what many within the Cleveland Diocesan administration, staff and parishes have known for several years. In a May 21, 2012 letter to all the priests of the diocese, Lennon wrote: “Over the past month, or so, I have become aware of a growing disconnect between many of the priests who serve so faithfully in this diocese and myself. It saddens me to hear reports that a number of our priests feel anxious and uncomfortable in my presence and that rather than being co-workers with me, a number of priests feel left out of consultation.” One can only take the Bishopʼs confession as a heartfelt expression.

Unfortunately, I would be remiss if I did not add that I believe a disconnect also exits between the Bishop and significant sectors of the lay Catholic Community, many religious leaders of other faiths in Northeast Ohio, many religious women and several civic and elected officials, who feel the Church has diminished its commitment to the region.

The Bishopʼs candor is striking for a number of reasons. Over the six full years since his installation as the tenth Bishop of Cleveland, Lennon has projected an image of being in total control of all things Catholic; laser like in his focus to tasks, no matter how small; the sole arbitrator of parish property; disinterested and impatient with honest dialogue; quick to label priests, staff or parishioners as disobedient or disloyal; and singularly committed to advancing his priorities. Some may give him high marks for his work ethic, commitment to matters of faith and morals, intense desire “to right size” the diocese, outreach to youth and young adults, and capacity as a fund raiser. Not many would give him high marks for his skills as a communicator, willingness to listen to diverse opinions, flexibility in correcting course, or for manifesting concern for the feelings of others.

What the Bishop has admitted is that the pastoral side of his leadership is somewhat lacking. As reported, at least three priests have called for his removal, 12 parishes are in the process of being reopened for his failure to comply with canon law, and two, long time popular and effective staff members summarily dismissed. What is not widely known is that Lennon was heavily criticized by members of his own priestʼs council after they learned of his shuttering of the Diocesan Pastoral Planning Office without their consultation. To many priests, this was the last straw and most likely precipitated the Bishop scheduling nine listening sessions with the priests of the diocese.

How one leads or shepherds oneʼs flock is every bit as important as what one accomplishes. Bishops are authentic teachers within the Catholic Church, however, this does not mean they cannot be servant leaders. It seems to me that in these challenging times, there is still a place for Bishops who act with humility, compassion, empathy, understanding, a sense of justice, a desire for personal conversion, an openness to discern the spirit and a love for all Godʼs people.

Bishop Lennon has pledged that he will come to the upcoming priest meetings and will “listen with an open heart.” If he is to regain the respect, trust and affection of his priests, he must not only listen…he must be open to changing his manner of leadership.

Tom Allio retired as the senior director of Cleveland Diocesan Social Action Office in March 2010.  He served the diocese for 32 1/2 years.

Quote | This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to “How one leads or shephe…

  1. Bob Kloos says:

    Well said, Tom. A clear assessment from a seasoned professional. We need many voices, clergy and lay, to join together asking the Bishop to step down. The listening sessions he has scheduled for his clergy are doomed. The Bishop set them up to fail. No school counselor would ever put a bully and the victim in the same room to sort things out. The imbalance of power is still there. The intimidation reigns. Nope, the priests should meet prior to the sessions with enough time to sort out the most significant issues. If it seems there is not sufficient confidence among them to urge +Richard Lennon to change, they could simply determine how many would respectfully ask the Bishop to step down immediately. Sign their names, and faithfully depart. He does not converse. There is nothing he really wants to work out. If that were the case, the downward spiral of the last six years would have seen a bright spot or two. There are none. He’s done. Let them say it loudly and clearly. Let us say it as well. The difference between what was handed to +RGL six years ago and now is surreal. Let’s do something right on behalf of the Diocese and we can get on with a year or two of recovery.

    • tony capozzi says:

      Tom, You have done a marvelous job with this article. I accept every word you have said. Everywhere I go I hear people talking about not liking the leadership this bishop has projected in our Diocese. They are unhappy in many many respects. We are seeing people actually leaving the church. Instead of working and blending together with all members of the Diocese, the Bishop has become a dictator and the church members slaves. Leadership and action of its members is a big part of the Catholic Church. He has taken that away. Social Justice work is a main part of the Catholic Church. One is the faith in God, the other is putting faith into action. That is the Catholic Church. That is the message and example that Jesus gave us in His life and teachings in the Bible. Not being able to openly perform these actions of faith is a sword in the heart, and driving people away. The Cleveland Diocese for many many years has been number one in the country in the work of Social Justice. Where do we stand now? Our Bishop needs to step down, and let our Diocese regrow in its true faith.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s